Kansas Voter ID Laws as Covered in the New York Times

In the New York Times article “Kansas Voter ID Law Sets Off a New Battle Over Registration,” Julie Bosman not only frames voter ID laws in warlike terms, but hardly covers both sides of this war equally. While Bosman does interview strict voting rule advocate Kris Kobach and allow him to have his say, his is the only conservative voice in the entire article.

The article begins with the personal story of a high school senior unable to vote due to the new Kansas voter registration laws. Bosman further notes that this senior believes these voter registration laws are “ridiculous and restrictive” due to these experiences; this senior, Bosman tells us, is an American teenager just like any other who is unable to vote thanks to “Republicans who dominate elected offices in Kansas.” Bosman’s choice of the word “dominate” already seems iffy; it brings to mind patriarchal, dictatorial overlords instead of elected politicians. And indeed, when she interviews Kobach, she makes sure to state that everything he says regarding voter registration laws are his own assertions. When she interviews Douglas Bonney, the legal director for the American Civil Liberties Union of Kansas, she doesn’t phrase his assertions as assertions; they’re merely facts.

Bosman also seems to pick and choose her evidence regarding Bonney and Kobach’s assertions. Bosman hardly looks at voter fraud, shooting down the idea that these voter registration laws prevent it in a mere two sentences. Instead, she looks at the idea that these laws are deliberately designed to prevent those who would vote for Democrats from voting, specifically looking at how hard the law hits young people; she pulls numbers from several polls to back up her claim that this is the case. Although Bosman frames her article as covering both sides of the “battle,” closer examination shows that Bosman is really biased toward the Democrats’ view of these laws.


Kansas Voter ID Laws as Covered in the New York Times

One thought on “Kansas Voter ID Laws as Covered in the New York Times

  1. This is a very interesting bias you have discovered, especially coming from a mainstream media like the New York Times. I enjoyed how, since the article has a war-esque vibe to it, you seemed to transfer that vibe into your blog post really well! It was interesting to read how Bosman made it seem like it was Kris Kobach against the “world” (which according to Bosman is the Democratic views). I agree with you on the bias present and surprised to see that this NYT article was one-sided. Seeing how New York Times is know for its objectivity, it was really enjoyable and interesting to see how even objective news sources can contain bias news articles.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s